Combination of Q-Switched Nd:YAG and Fractional Erbium: YAG Lasers in Treatment of Melasma: A Randomized Controlled Clinical Trial

Abstract

Introduction: Ablative and nonablative lasers have been used to treat melasma. We aimed to assess and compare the combining Q-switched Nd:YAG laser (QSNYL) and fractional erbium: YAG laser (FEYL) with QSNYL alone in treatment of melasma. Methods: This randomized controlled clinical trial was performed in our Research Center during 2013-2014. Women with melasma and without a history of keloid formation, hypersensitivity to hydroquinone, or pigmentary changes due to laser therapy were randomly allocated to receive four sessions of either QSNYL-FEYL combination or QSNYL alone. All patients received topical treatment with Kligman's formula. Before laser therapy and 4 weeks after the last treatment session, patients' skin was assessed for changes in skin color, melanin content, and erythema intensity of melasma lesions quantitatively. Results: Finally, 21 patients in QSNYL-FEYL and 20 in QSNYL group (mean age, 38.57 5.60 and 42.60 8.44 years, respectively) completed study. The skin color had become lighter in both groups (mean SD percentage change of 56.95 40.29 and 29.25 13.20 in QSNYL-FEYL and QSNYL groups, respectively) with significantly better results in QSNYL-FEYL group (P = 0.006). Percentage of decrease of melanin content was significantly higher in QSNYL-FEYL group (22.01 10.67 vs. 7.69 4.75; P < 0.001). After adjustment for baseline values, the post treatment intensity of erythema was significantly lower in QSNYL-FEYL group (P < 0.001). The patients reported no adverse events. Conclusion: QSNYL-FEYL was significantly more effective in decreasing melanin content of lesions than QSNYL and led to a lighter skin.